We allowed the designated hitter in all of baseball, not just the American League. We determined that chest hair on men was undesirable. We decided that Christopher Columbus, Thomas Jefferson and Mahatma Gandhi were bad guys, not good guys.
Times change. Things are different now than they were 20, 40 or 60 years ago. Adapt or die.
That's all fine, but this is a bridge too far: They're trying to change the tune and flow of the Alphabet song. Yes. That song.
The one you sang to learn the alphabet. The "elemen-o-pee" song. They're changing that one. Or attempting to do so (and by "they," I means some people on the internet).
It's an outrage that could disrupt the entire educational system. It's a change that shouldn't be made.
We can change our view of O.J. Simpson and decide that Harry Truman was a good president and admit that disco music wasn't that bad. But can we change the flow of the ABC song that shares a tune with "Baa-Baa Black Sheep" and "Twinkle, Twinkle Little Star"?
There's plenty of reason to say no, but the biggest reason is that the proponents of the new version (new = the earliest version I can find of it is from 2019) are trying to take away the part of the song we like the most. You know, the "elemen-o-pee" part.
I presume there's a reason for it. They think little kids will get confused and not realize that L, M, N, O and P are letters. They're right, but that's not a reason to change it. Generations of kids have learned the alphabet despite the "elemen-o-pee" portion. Maybe because of it.
Perhaps the confusion makes the magic.
Things don't have to be perfect to work. There's value in learning how to drive in an old, imperfect car. It's OK to take vacations where everything doesn't come out perfectly. Sometimes, the best meal can be food that's not perfectly prepared.
And there's value in the traditional version of the Alphabet song.
If we let them change the tune and flow of the Alphabet song, what's next? Will we try to make everything easy for kids? Will we stop having to, two and too mean different things? Will we stop talking about Persia, Prussia and Russia as different places? Will we stop telling them 4 is more than 2, but ¼ is less than ½?
No, no and no. But each of those makes more sense than changing the Alphabet song.
If we change the tune and flow (let's face it, we're changing the lyrics if we take out elemen-o-pee) to the Alphabet song, everything could be on the table. And that's a frightening proposition.
Just say no to the new Alphabet song.
Now I've said my ABCs, next time won't you sing with me?
Reach Brad Stanhope at bradstanhope@outlook.com.